Lord of the Rings: The Animated Musical | Victorian Travel Safety

While Tolkien was a medieval scholar, the culture of his hobbits seemed inspired by the Victorian and Edwardian eras, the time of his childhood. Early 20th century England was drastically different than Medieval England. Technology had rapidly advanced, allowing travelers to use steamships and trains rather than going by foot, while travelogues tended to be more accurate than for previous generations. However, many aspects of travel had not changed. Crime rates were still high, and communication was nowhere near as fast or as consistent as we know today.

Travelogues

With the rise of industrialization during the First Industrial Revolution from the 1760s to 1830s and the Second Industrial Revolution from the 1870s through the 1910s, new technology allowed people to travel at a speed previously unknown to humankind. Industrialization also brought scientific innovation to every corner of life, including travel. Now people would not just take a grand tour of Europe or visit “exotic” lands like newly opened China. They could do this “correctly”.

In 1836, young author John Murray II used his connections to his father’s London-based publishing company to print A Handbook for Travellers on the Continent: Being a Guide to Holland, Belgium, Prussia, Northern Germany, and the Rhine from Holland to Switzerland. The book included lists or formulas to take in as many sites and sights in the country as possible given the short time people were able to spend in the area. Wealthy persons, both past and present, have decried this development as contributing to the rise of tourism. Others have noted that these guides allow the average person to see the world in relative safety.

These books also shed light on areas otherwise unknown to the everyday traveller. When reading the seventh edition of the book — Murray seems to have published twelve — even I with my education and virtually unlimited internet in the 21st century did not recognize all of the cities. Vienna, Paris, Geneva, and Berlin were among the many I found familiar, but I had not heard of Mavence, Gratz, Trieste, or St. Malo. As for Murray, he inherited his father’s publishing business and made many authors famous, including Jane Austen, Charles Darwin, and Lord Byron, whose memoirs he allegedly burned in his office fireplace after the man’s death. The publishing business was passed from John Murray to John Murray until John Murray VII, who sold the business in 2002; John Murray Press is still in operation under Hachette UK, itself a part of the massive conglomerate Lagardere Group.

Let’s get back to the Victorian era. For those who wished for an even more scientific approach, Hints to travellers, scientific and general by the Royal Geographic Society of Great Britain was another popular book available in two volumes, although it was filled with advertisements for fur-lined overcoats, field watches, boots, tents, and deck chairs. I have found the sixth edition, seventh edition, eighth edition, ninth edition, and tenth edition available online. Each follows a similar format. Much of the first volume is dedicated to astronomy, geography, trigonometry, and other mapping techniques not so different than what was used by medieval travelers. The second volume describes newer disciplines including meteorology, photography, natural history, anthropology, archaeology, and medicine. This style of travel was not for the faint of heart.

A companion to this book, published in multiple editions between 1854 and 1860 by John Murray’s press in London, was The art of travel; or, Shifts and contrivances available in wild countries by Francis Galton. His book was inspired by his work in South Africa and encouraged other young men to “rough it” in “the Bush, the Desert, the Prairie, the Ice, the Water-side and the Jungle” (Galton, 2). He focused on finding water, starting a fire, cooking, and a dozen other skills. It is not unlike modern guides for living off the grid or in a van.

Travelogues and survival guides were not options for Frodo and company. While they had grown up hearing the stories of Bilbo’s adventures, the “dear old hobbit” was too easily distracted to finish his memoirs until nearly the end of The Lord of the Rings. Additionally, Bilbo played down the dangers of his travels, calling his trip a casual “there and back again”. Even though Frodo was an avid reader, he had no chance to find a book that would allow him to learn these skills.

The Crime Continues

Medieval England was dangerous for travelers, and Victorian London likewise was more unsafe than today. According to statistics found in Crime and society in England, 1750-1900 by Clive Emsley, a British historian and criminologist who worked for the Open University, there were a combined 273 highway robberies in Liverpool and Manchester during 1860 with 246 of the robbers apprehended (Emsley, 27). Terms for crimes were inconsistent at the time, as robbery in one town might be called larceny in another depending on how much the local police force tolerated physical violence. One common form of violence was garroting, or strangling a victim in order to rob them.

Statisticians at the time shared what could generously be called rough estimates on the number of “loose criminals” in cities. Patrick Colquhoun, a Lord Provost of Glasgow who in 1797 wrote A Treatise on the Police of the Metropolis, estimated that 115,000 people in London survived on crime instead of a job, while 2,000 of these were dangerous; his proposed solution appeared to be more wars to put these people in the army (Emsley, 64). Colquhoun’s many good ideas, at least to people at the time, led to the University of Glasgow awarding him an honorary Doctor of Laws (LLD) the same year that his book came out. The next year in 1798, he founded the Thames River Police with John Harriott, who was, according to the Dictionary of National Biography, a somewhat ordinary sailor that wrote letters to more famous and wealthy people to get a police force on the river until someone actually listened and put him in charge. Nobody seemed to like Harriott, but the police cutter patrol did seemingly cut down on crime.

As thoroughly described in the Prologue, at the time Frodo and his friends began their journey, a number of shirriffs were employed, marking their position with a feather in their hat instead of a uniform. The shirriffs mostly collected stray animals or worked as Bounders to guard the borders of the Shire. The “lockholes” in the capital Michel Delving seemed to rarely be used. In fact, with the exception of naughty hobbit children stealing apples and mushrooms or annoying relatives taking spoons, hobbits of the Shire do not appear to commit crimes. This led the poor shirriffs to be completely unprepared when Saruman took over their little country. They would have offered no help if Frodo had asked for assistance when escaping the Ringwraiths.