American Antiquarian Society | The American Revolution on Trial
I recently watched the webinar The American Revolution on Trial featuring author T.H. Breen, who published a book by the same name with the University of Virginia Press in March 2026. The webinar was sponsored by American Antiquarian Society with Vice Chair Dr. Ros Remer acting as the host. Breen is a member of the Society who loves old books and had purchased a 1778 publication titled The Proceedings of a Court-Martial held at Cambridge, Massachusetts by order of Major General Heath Commanding the American Troops for the Northern District for the Trial of Colonel David Henley Accused by General Burgoyne of Ill Treatment of British Soldiers. This unusual book inspired Breen to write his own book about the trial, detailing how a British prisoner of war demanded a court-martial of an American soldier.
Breen set the scene for the trial. In October 1778, the Battle of Saratoga had ended with the surrender of General John Burgoyne and his army of 6,000 troops, half of which spoke German. Burgoyne agreed to march his troops to the Boston area, where they would then be paroled back to England. However, George Washington thought this was a bad idea. Those troops could sail straight back to America and then go to the Philadelphia area, Valley Forge, where much the Colonial Army was stationed. Once in Cambridge, which had a population of 1,500 at the time, German soldiers were separated from British soldiers. The British were sent to a camp at Prospect Hill. Burgoyne was humiliated and scared of going back to England, so he complained bitterly about the strained food and sanitation resources. The Continental Congress debated what to do about the Burgoyne and his troops until they, according to Breen, “came up with an absolutely brilliant solution”. They sent a letter for George III asking what to do. If the king responded, it would force him to recognized the United States as its own country. If he did not respond, they could keep the prisoners of war indefinitely. Burgoyne was obviously not happy about this situation.
The man in charge of the camp was a 29-year-old colonel named David Henley whose brother had been killed by the British the year before. Between his age, his grief over his brother, and the fact that many of the approximately 1,000 soldiers under him were 14-year-olds from the local Massachusetts militias, Henley made a few poor choices. When a drunk British prisoner caused a disruption, Henley poked him with a sword. Another time, a group of British prisoners scared a group of mostly teenaged American guards, prompting one guard to poke a prisoner with his sword. The doctors called in for both occations attested that no one was seriously hurt, just acting foolish. Despite fears of a massive prison breakout, this never happened, likely because the British soldiers believed they were soon going home. Not all the poor choices belonged to Henley. Burgoyne asked Glover to take him on a tour of Massachusetts. Glover was delighted and wrote to Washington about this great idea; fortunately, Washington wrote back in time to stop the tour, as Burgoyne could have recorded all the vulnerabilities in Massachusetts and then escaped.
Because of the poor choices, Burgoyne demanded to have Henley court-martialed, claiming that he planned “an intentional murder”. Strangely enough, Major General William Heath accepted this proposal, and a court was set up. The President of the Court was General John Glover of Marblehead, MA who had recently rowed Washington’s army across the Delaware. Trial started in January 1778 and lasted for three weeks due to snowstorms shutting down court. Burgoyne told General Heath that he wanted to serve as the prosecutor, even though military trials typically do not have prosecutors. Burgoyne’s argument mostly hinged around Americans being uncivilized, not the type of language to make one popular with an all-American panel of adjutant judges. The judge advocate, similar to a defense lawyer, was William Tudor who had just finished up his studies reading law under John Adams, perhaps the most famous lawyer in Massachusetts if the not the United States at the time. Newspapers of all persuasions described Tudor as “a manly, determined spirit” who declared that the British “have no better right to superiority over us than a Frenchman, a Spaniard, a native of Japan…” Breen believes that the jury of ten officers “probably debated for at least 10 seconds… and declared Henley innocent of the charges”.
Just before everyone left, Henley challenged Burgoyne to a duel. However, he then remembered that as an officer of the Continental Army, he was not allowed to duel. They decided the duel would take place in Bermuda after the war was over. By the time the war ended, neither felt like dueling anymore. Henley became a provisional governor instead. As for Burgoyne, he returned to England, where he asked George III to court-martial him so he would have a platform to explain what went wrong. George III gave him no platform. Then Burgoyne went home to his estate and continued his preferred work as a playwright. Breen admitted, “The plays, I can assure you, are absolutely unreadable”. George III actually had a much better, if briefer, relationship with William Tudor. Tudor became a celebrated lawyer in Boston and eventually had an audience with George III who quipped, “Ah, Mr. Tudor, you must be my relative”, as the royal family of England had once been known as the House of Tudor.
The number of prisoners of wars dwindled throughout the war. The German soldiers were paid to be there and according to Breen, “they thought America looked pretty good, and a lot of Germans kind of disappeared into the hinterland” especially in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, marrying into the local population. By the end of the war, between 600 and 800 prisoners of war remained imprisoned, but they seemed to have fairly good conditions. A few German officers taught then-governor Thomas Jefferson to play a harpsichord. Even with the good will between Americans and German soldiers, Burgoyne was always hated, especially by women. Hannah Winthrop, Abigail Adams, and Mercy Otis Warren all wrote about their hatred of him. For colonial women, his worse atrocity might have been ruining couch cushions and defacing mahogany furniture, as no accounts written by men ever mentioned the furniture debacle.
This fun and fast-paced talk covered a rarely remembered moment in the American Revolutionary War, reminding the audience how strange this period of history really was. The recording of the webinar is available online: